The Inventory Genius Podcast
The Inventory Genius Podcast
#253: Green Flags, Red Flags When Hiring a Consultant
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
I’ve never shared this on the podcast before, but it’s long overdue.
I work with so many small business owners who’ve been burned by consultants and coaches—promised the world and left with disappointment. And honestly? It fires me up. No consultant should ever take advantage of a client’s trust, especially when that client is trying to grow something meaningful.
As business owners, we often hire help when we’re stretched thin or searching for answers. We want to believe someone can step in and deliver results. But how do you know if you’re hiring the right person?
In this episode, I’m breaking down exactly what you should expect when working with a consultant:
- The red flags to watch for
- What a healthy consultant-client relationship looks like
- And how to track real progress once they’re on board
If you’ve ever hired a consultant—or you’re thinking about it—this episode will give you the clarity you need to make smart, confident decisions.
Get a FREE MONTH with the Inventory Genius Calculator - https://www.ciarastockeland.com/inventory-genius-calculator
Work with Me - https://www.ciarastockeland.com/work-with-me
Visit the Bookstore - https://www.ciarastockeland.com/bookstore
Sign Up for Free Weekly Tips and Trainings - https://www.ciarastockeland.com/subscribe
If your sales are growing but your cash isn't, let's find out why.
Get the Inventory Genius Operating System: https://ciarastockeland.com/program
Shop the Bookstore: https://www.ciarastockeland.com/bookstore
Sign Up for Free Weekly Tips and Trainings: https://www.ciarastockeland.com/subscribe
Hey friends, do I have something exciting for you? Oh my goodness, guys, I am so excited because the Inventory Genius Open to Buy calculator is lost. That is right. Easy at your fingertips, throw a couple numbers in and calculate your monthly open to buy. Or you can do your weekly open to buy, or you can do your annual open to buy. This calculator makes buying so easy. It also includes a calculator so that you can measure and track your inventory turn. So I want to give you a free month to the Inventory Genius calculator. You'll find the link in the show notes. Hey friend, welcome to the Inventory Genius podcast, where we work together here to make you an inventory genius. We talk about profit, we talk about cash flow, and we definitely talk about your paycheck. Because at the end of the day, it's all related to your inventory. Let's go. Hey everyone, welcome to the Inventory Genius Podcast. I'm your host, Sierra, and today we're going to talk about something that I've literally never talked about here before on the podcast, at least in this way before. And we've been doing this podcast for a lot of years now. So there's been quite a few episodes. But I, you know, I really want to talk to you about this idea of what you should look for in a consultant today. Um, because I run into so many small business owners that have hired consultants and coaches and have been completely burned. And I will tell you when I hear those stories, you guys, it fires me up because I don't think any consultant should ever take advantage of one of their clients. Um, and I think a lot of times as small business owners, we are so desperate, desperate for help that we, you know, we want to believe that we're gonna get the best out of someone when we hire them for their expertise and their help. And we don't really know what to expect. We don't really know how that relationship should look. And I don't want you leaving disappointed. So today we're gonna break down what to expect when you hire a consultant. And I hope that today, at the end of this episode, you are gonna leave with real clarity on what you should expect from a consultant, what the red flags are, and what the progress looks like that you should be making after you bring someone like that onto your team. All right, let's dig in and get started. So I want to start with a little bit of my story. I know some of you guys know my story, some of you don't, but I'm just gonna share my story a little bit. I haven't done that on this podcast for a while either. Um, but it ties into what you should look for in a consultant. I'm gonna give you a little bit of the backstory of some really bad consultants I had and are one really phenomenal consultant that completely changed the life of my business and in fact is continuing to help change the lives of all of you because of what he taught me. So we're gonna talk about that. All right, so I started my first retail store in 2006, and I had never worked a day of retail in my life. I had other small businesses. In fact, my first small business I started when I was 13, built that and grew it for about a decade, and then I decided my next venture was going to be a retail venture. I had never worked a day of retail in my life, but I thought, hey, I'd like to build a brand. I want a brick and mortar store. And so I opened my first retail store in 2006 in downtown Fargo. It was a high-end maternity baby store. And um, I, you know, in fact, I remember going to market for the first time. I had no idea what I was doing. I had, I didn't even know what the term open to buy was. I had no idea how much to spend on inventory. The way that I figured out what to buy, you guys, was literally the square footage of my retail store. I bought the racks, put the racks in, bought hangers to fit them, counted the hangers, and then decided how many things I should buy. Which, you know, it kind of sort of worked. But um, I mean, I was green. I knew nothing. What I did have though was a tank full of optimism. And I knew that if I told someone I was, you know, capable of something, I would be. And I would be honest with people. And I knew that I would always hold up my end of the deal. And so it never occurred to me that I could or would end up hiring people who promised a lot and didn't deliver. And so I started by hiring a bookkeeper. Now I tried to do my books myself for a while because a lot of us make this mistake, right? We're gonna invest everything, including hearth and home, into our businesses, but yet we're gonna manage the accounting, which we have no idea how to do or any business doing. We should be on the floor selling, we should be procuring inventory, we should be merchandising, all the things that we're really good at. But we decide that, you know, when we're gonna cut costs, it's gonna be in the bookkeeping side of things. And I was no different. So I got QuickBooks and I decided to do QuickBooks on my own. Well, I had no clue what I was doing, and I didn't like it. And so, you know, like many of you, um, and so it didn't get done and all the things. So eventually I decided I'm gonna hire a bookkeeper. So I hired a bookkeeper local to the Fargo area, and um, she a female bookkeeper, so I was excited. I felt like, okay, you know, I liked her vibe, I liked her personality, all the things. Um, she started doing my books, and so we could consider this a consultant of sorts, right? So this was a vendor partner. Um, I had QuickBooks and QuickBooks Point of Sale. So QuickBooks was my accounting system, QuickBooks Point of Sale, which is no longer, it was fantastic, by the way. I wish they still had it, but QuickBooks Point of Sale was my point of sale and they integrated nicely. So um I hired her to do my books. The first thing that I now know is an issue was that my cost of goods, like how she was entering that, was not accurate. Now I had no idea what it should look like, so I didn't know that it was inaccurate. But what I did know is I didn't understand what the papers were telling me. So she would give me the financials and I would ask questions. This doesn't make sense. Tell me where this should be. Why am I feeling like I'm missing things here? And a lot of her answers were, um, I don't know. I mean, I don't know, I don't really handle things like that. And she kind of pushed me off. So eventually I got really frustrated with this because I thought, hey, I'm paying this person who's supposed to be a professional to give me a professional answer when it comes to my accounting. I don't feel comfortable with this. And so I ended up moving on from her. The next accounting firm that I hired um was bigger, and um it was run by a guy who um who had a really big ego, let's just say. Okay. So he was one of those people who loves to tell you how smart he is. And so um he worked the firm, he he owned the firm, and then he assigned a bookkeeper to me. The bookkeeper was a very nice gentleman. Um, but same issues. I would ask questions, he wouldn't really help me understand things. I felt at a loss. And what broke the straw on the camel's back was I had decided to franchise, or I was thinking about franchising. And I remember I went, I made an appointment with my accountant because that's your partner, right? In a way, that's a consultant. They're working for you, they're helping you, they're consulting, or they should be, on the state of your business. So I thought I'm gonna ask him what he thinks and you know, any red flags and what should I be thinking about? So I made an appointment. I was sitting at his conference table and I explained, here's what I want to do. I want to franchise. And he looked at me and said, No one's ever gonna buy that from you, Sierra. Your business says no, yeah, you cannot franchise. Like, who would buy your business? It was so condescending and rude that I decided we're moving on. Like, I need not only a partner that I saw I didn't have in that first bookkeeper, someone that could explain things and help me understand and had answers or could find them. I also needed someone who believed in me, not someone who would blindly go along. I would have been completely fine if he said, Hey Sierra, here's some things to think about. I want you to be cautious and I want you to really understand the cost and really understand the time commitment. I would have loved that. But what he did do was look at me and say, my idea was stupid. And in fact, I was not capable of it, right? No, I needed a partner who believed in me. Fast forward many years, about a decade, I was in financial trouble, which you guys know a lot of that part of the story, right? Which is how I'm here helping you all today. Um, and I was gun shy when it came to bookkeepers and accountants. I in between now fast forwarding and that last firm that didn't believe in me, I ended up hiring someone internally. So she was my employee that did my accounting. She was lovely. Um, but I was in financial trouble. And um, someone recommended a gentleman to me that did what I do for all of you. He was a financial strategist. He helped businesses that were in trouble get from financial stress to financial freedom. He helped them get out of debt. So the things that I do for all of you, that's what he did for small businesses. He worked across all different industries. And so someone recommended him. I was nervous, but I met with him the first time and it was amazing, you guys. Sitting down, the questions he asked, how he believed in me when I could no longer believe in myself, how he was willing to explain things and help me understand. That finally gave me the opportunity to see what a good consultant could do for a business. And that's what I want to talk to you about today. So that's my story. Let's talk about why you would hire a consultant in the first place. Now, those first two examples, those were accountants slash bookkeepers, right? So we were, I wasn't really hiring them as a consultant. Um, but they had a consultant type conversation or role in my business because of the type of work that they did. Because they were in the financials, I was expecting them to give me some consultancy, right? Some answers, some questions. The third gentleman that I talked about, the one who really clarified things for me and opened my eyes to how the finances and cash flow and inventory worked, he was hired as a consultant. So, what is a consultant? A consultant is someone that you bring into your business that can look big picture, that can see the overall picture of your business, they can look at the big picture, and they can help you create a specific strategy. So, in my case, I'm a financial consultant. I'm a contract CFO, I'm a profit strategist. I'm gonna help you when it comes to anything numbers related. So whether that's inventory, cash flow, debt management, financial acumen, if it is financial related, if it has a dollar sign in front of it, if it has a number sign in front of it, that falls into my wheelhouse. Okay, so I'm a financial consultant. You can hire consultants in lots of areas, marketing consultants, people consultants, leadership consultants. So consultants typically have a very specific skill set that you can hire them for and they can apply that to your business so that they can create a big picture strategy to either move you from a place of stress to freedom or to help you grow your business, strategic, you know, moves that you need to make in your business. So the reason that you would hire a consultant in the first place is because you feel that something in your business is lacking. There's an area of your business that you are not capable of figuring out, managing, strategizing on your own. You need a third party that can come in with a specific skill set and help you create a strategy or a plan around it. Like I said, in my experience, what I do with clients is help them move from financial stress to financial freedom. So first we we look at what that stress is in their business. Is it stress around debt? Is it stress around cash flow? Is it stress around too much growth too quickly? Where's the stress, the financial stress coming from? Then we create a clear picture that will then move them into financial freedom. So the reason that it's hard to do these big picture tasks on your own as an owner is because you are so in the muck and mire of your business. You get very much like that blindfold idea of like having blindfolds on, only being able to look at something one way, getting really stuck in a rut, all of these things, right? We sometimes um owners get paralyzed by fear. So I don't know what to do, so I'm just not gonna do anything. A consultant that is a good consultant can come in and can show you where the gaps are, where the opportunities are, and they can create that picture for you with step-by-step action and then hold you accountable to it. As an owner, it's hard to do all of those things on your own, to figure out what the problem is, to create a big picture strategy around it and to hold yourself accountable. That's a lot of a lot to ask of yourself, right? When you are running and doing all of the other things, not to mention that you're probably not specifically gifted in that area that you're looking to hire a consultant in. Now, here's a warning for you: hiring a consultant just because it sounds like the next step is a mistake. You need to be hiring a consultant because you are being intentional about your next step. So if you're sitting here and you're thinking, yeah, I mean, I haven't ever hired a consultant, maybe that's what I should do. That is not the reason to hire someone. Okay. The reason you would hire a consultant is because you are being intentional about the next step in your business. I need to get out of debt. I don't know how to do it on my own. I will hire someone that does know how to do it that can help me and hold me accountable. In the case of marketing, I know I need to market my business and create a brand story. I really don't know how to do it on my own. So I'm going to bring someone in that can help me create an overall brand story and vision for my business, put together a plan to execute and hold me accountable to it. That is why you would hire a consultant. Okay, so what does a good consultant look like? Here's some key traits that you should be looking for when you are hiring a consultant. So when you're talking to a consultant, when you're doing a consult call, these are the traits that you should be looking for. Number one, they have to have a clarity in their process. Okay, they should have a framework, not just someone giving you random advice. You guys, this is why I always thought consultants were a croc. Honestly, I was like, really, you just sit on the phone and you get paid to talk to people. I think that's that's not a real job. I honestly thought that for many years. I have I never set out to do what I do today, but I do it because I know how to get the work done. I have the experience of doing it the right way and the wrong way and then the right way again, right? So I've learned from experience, trial and error. Um, I know exactly what my clients need and how to get them there as quickly as possible. How do I get them to the front of the line? And so I ended up being a financial and strategy consultant because I love what I do, I have the answers, I have the experience, and I created a framework and a process to get people from A to Z. So I don't just sit on the phone and give random advice. There's a framework that I follow. So when you are looking to hire a consultant, you should be looking for someone who has a clarity of process. They have a framework that they use. Number two, that they are results-oriented. They should be able to give you what clear milestones look like and what measurable outcomes look like. Not just, yeah, we're gonna grow. Yeah, you're gonna feel better. No, clear milestones, stones, and measurable outcomes. When we are done working together, this is what your business will look like. As we work along the way, here's where I want to get you first, and then here's where I want to get you second. They should be results-oriented. Number three, their communication needs to be put in place in a form that gives you deliverables. If you are paying for a consultant, you should have a list of deliverables from them. In other words, I communicate Monday through Friday, 10 to 5. I do one call a month every, you know, one call every month with my clients. These are some examples. I coach on over Voxer. We do a group call twice a month. They should have a clear system of communication and they should be delivering that communication system within your contract without you hounding them or asking for it. Okay. So, number one, clarity of process. They should have a framework, not just give random advice. Number two, they should be results-oriented, have clear milestones and measurable outcomes that they can tell you you will receive or that they're gonna work with you on. Number three, they should have a communication process so that you know exactly when and how you'll be communicating with them. And then this is really important too. Number four, they should fit within your business values. Okay. So if it's really important to you as a business owner that family comes first and that we're getting you out of debt so that you can be with your family, then the consultant you hire needs to buy into that. They need to agree with that set of values. Because if you hire a consultant that says, no, no, no, the only thing you should be thinking about is growing, growing, growing, opening multiple locations, becoming a millionaire, working four hours a week so that you can just, you know, travel around the world and you have tons of money. If that's what their value set looks like, but that's not your value set, it doesn't matter if they have a process, if they communicate clearly, and if they're results oriented, at the end of the day, their values and your values won't align. And so the consultancy will not work well. Okay, so next, I want to talk about what you should expect as the client. Okay, so this is what you should expect from your consultant, okay? What you should look for, the traits you should look for. Now, what should you expect as a client? So from day one, a consultant should have an onboarding process. What does it look like to get you started? Once they sign you up, do they have, you know, certain things that you fill out for them? Um, are there some forms? Do they gather information? Do they introduce you to the team? Um, do they get you on the schedule? What does the onboarding process look like? You should also expect ongoing accountability, progress tracking, any type of education that they might have within their framework, things that empower you and don't confuse you. You guys, I'm gonna go over some red flags, but I'm gonna interject right here with this one. If you have hired someone that makes you feel stupid when you ask questions, that talks down to you, or that talks in jargon in doctores, so you can't understand it and you feel silly, that is not a good consultant. And ongoing accountability, progress tracking, education, and someone that has things that can empower you, not confuse you. A good consultant also has boundaries. So you should expect from your consultant honesty, but not hand holding. If you have a consultant that will do everything for you, so in other words, they give themselves homework instead of giving you homework, that's not good. A consultant should be there to empower you to learn how to fish so that they can let you go. A good consultant wants you to finish the project with them, be empowered to do it on your own going forward, and then walk free. If you have someone that ties you in and just, you know, really holds on to you and won't really teach you, they always tell you that you're gonna need them forever. That's not a great consultant, okay? Because they're in it for them, they're not in it for you. So again, what should you expect? You should expect someone who has an onboarding process, they listen to you, they set you up for success. You should expect someone that has and is giving you ongoing accountability, progress tracking, education, something that, you know, they're they're constantly looking for ways to empower you, not to confuse you more or to hold you hostage. And someone that has good boundaries, someone that's honest, that won't do the work for you, and that will tell you when you need to shape up or ship out. You want a consultant that is honest in a loving way that says, hey, here's the deal. If we don't make progress, you're gonna lose your business. Now I know we can keep your business and I know we can make it happen. It's gonna take some work, but I'm also not gonna sugarcoat it. This is tough. This is hard. You want someone who can be honest and open with you while holding you accountable and wishing you the ability to fish on your own. All right. So how do you know if your consultant is working now? So here's some signs if that you're with the right consultant. Number one, you should feel clearer, not more confused. Okay. Number two, you're seeing measurable progress. Now, sometimes progress is slow, and that's okay. Okay, think about going to the gym to lose weight or think about learning to, you know, starting to do strength. It takes a long time to see some of those results, but you should see some of those results. Okay. So signs you're with the right consultant, you're feeling clearer, not more confused. You're seeing measurable progress. And number three, and this is what I love and I hope my clients feel that you're feeling supported but also challenged. I want to add something to this line here, feeling supported but also challenged. I love my clients. For those of you guys who work with me, I just want to know because I know a lot of you listen to the podcast. I love working with you. It is my honor and privilege to work with you on your businesses. In fact, I'm looking at my board right now. I have every one of my clients' names up on my board, whether they're in level one, level two, or level three. Um, I have each and every one of your names up on my board so I can think about you and think about your projects. It's my honor and my joy to work with you. I want you to feel supported, but it's also my job as a consultant to challenge you to do more, to challenge you. To be better. And I can do that because I know you can. I know that you can do the hard things that you you don't feel like you can do. I know that you can win in ways that you can't even envision. And that's what a good consultant can do for you as a client. They can hold those beliefs because we've seen it. I've seen my clients win time and time again. It's hard sometimes for the client to feel like they can get those wins or do those big things because you haven't done them before, right? But as a consultant, as a good consultant, I can hold that belief for you until you're ready to believe it yourself. And so a good consultant will help you feel clear, not more confused. You just start seeing good, measurable progress and results, and you should always feel supported, not challenged. Here's some red flags. Okay. Take out a pen and paper. I want you to write these down. So in the future, when you think about hiring a consultant to help you in your business, I want you to remember these red flags. Number one, they're always selling you the next thing. Okay. That kind of goes back to what we talked about a little bit earlier, not teaching you to fish. A consultant that truly cares about their client wants them to win and to learn how to win on their own and then let them go to go do it. You guys are smart people. Like you are business owners. I don't want you to forget that. Small business owners are some of the most intelligent people in the world. You are problem solvers. You are creative. You might just be in a really hard spot right now, and that's okay. But you are smart. You are intelligent. You can figure this out with a little help and guidance. And so if you have a consultant that's constantly selling you the next, oh, you need to do that. You can't, oh, you gotta keep me forever. Nope, you gotta, you gotta do this, you gotta keep me, you gotta pay me more. That's a red flag. Number two, bigger red flag for me, because this happens a lot. I see it. So I'll go into a business that's financially stressed, and a lot of times they have been trying to figure things out. And so they've hired consultants, they've signed on people. And um, when I start asking questions, like, okay, we're paying X this person X amount of money, tell me what their deliverables are, tell me what they're doing for you, tell me what's working, what's not working, we don't get answers. That is a red flag. If you have a consultant and you have no clear deliverables or accountability, right? Because progress takes time, but if you don't have someone that's holding you accountable, in other words, they have a routine check-in call with me, they have a way to measure and track results, they provide me with an agenda. There's all different ways that a good consultant can give deliverables and provide accountability. But if you have someone working for you and you're paying them and they're not doing those things, red flag. Number three, you dread meeting them instead of looking forward to meeting them. Now, this isn't to say that sometimes these calls are hard, right? I do a lot of hard calls, and there's a difference between, oh my goodness, I don't want to get on the call with her because she's so rude and she makes me feel so stupid. And there's a difference between that and I'm super nervous to talk to Sierra this week because I just found out I have a tax bill that I didn't know about and I don't know what we're gonna do. Like I don't know where the money's gonna come from. That's a completely different dread, if you will, in air quotes. The feeling of I don't want to talk to this person because they make me feel stupid, they make me feel small, they're they make me feel more confused than when I started the phone call. That's completely different than I'm nervous to get on the phone, the week didn't go very well, I didn't do my homework, that's a completely different thought. So if you have a consultant that you dread meeting with instead of looking forward to it, another big red flag. Okay, in closing, when do you keep and when do you fire a consultant? Number one, and this kind of goes back to what we've been talking about, you keep them if they continue to bring clarity and challenge and results to your business. If someone continues to bring more clarity, there's more for you to learn, there's more for you to simplify, there's more for you to get results in, you keep that person. You fire them if you've outgrown them, if they stop adding value, or if they do not respect your business goals. Okay? Your business goals. That goes back to what I said. Like if their goal for every single client they have is to make them a multimillionaire and that is not your goal, that doesn't align. Okay, get rid of them because it's not gonna change. So you keep them if they continue to bring clarity, challenge, and results. You get rid of them if you've outgrown them, they stop adding value, or they don't respect your goals. Frame it as a stewardship of your time and money, okay? You have a limited amount of time, and probably if you're listening to the Inventory Genius podcast, you have an even more limited amount of money. I want you to be a good steward of that time and a good steward of that money. And that means if you have a consultant that you're working with that is rude to you, that they aren't delivering, they don't show up for calls, they have no framework, you've known in your gut for months now that they are not a good fit, get rid of them today. Be the boss of your business, take ownership, move on. Likewise, if you know that there are areas of your business that you just can't do alone, that we're just not making progress in, that you are ready to take that next step to solve that big problem and you need clarity, then it's time for you to hire a consultant. Okay. So, action here, this is what it looks like. I want you to think about the people that are on your team. I want you to think about consultants that you've perhaps had in the past where it hasn't worked out. How have they, how have they fallen into some of these parameters I've given you today on our conversation? I want you to think about that. And I want you to think about this encouraging statement as we close, that the right consultant should be a partner in your success, not a burden of your business. And so if you have partners in your business that you've hired, so these are not people that are partners on paper that you're stuck with, but you know, people that you've paid vendor partners, bookkeepers, accountants, consultants, coaches, and they are a burden on your business instead of a partner in your success, it is time for you to cut ties and to move on. And if you are looking for someone to help you, of course, I would love to be that person. If it has anything to do with financials or inventory, I would love to provide you clarity. I would love to have the opportunity to give you a good experience with a consultant, especially for those of you who have been burned in the past. I would love to be the person that can give you a good experience on what a true consultant partner should look like. Um, and so if you're interested in that and you're looking for help, you know where you can find me, Sierra Stockland.com. If you go to my website and go to the work with me page, um, there's a list there of different ways we can work together. I would love to do that. Please connect with me and let me know what you thought of today's episode. Like I said, it fires me up when I hear about business owners who are taken advantage of because they have partnered with really bad consultants and business coaches because I know quite a few really good consultants, honestly. I'm I work in a space where I know consultants is in other industries and they are phenomenal. So I know that people are out there that do care about your success, that can give you actionable results, that can hold you accountable while also challenging you. Um, and so if you've been Burt in the past, I just want to encourage you to try again. Find someone that fits within the green floods and flags and the red flags that we talked about today. Look for someone that can really help you take the next step forward in your business. Don't ever feel like you have to do this alone. All right, thank you for tuning in this week. We'll see y'all next week. Bye for now. Hey, friend, thank you so much for tuning in today to the Inventory Genius Podcast. If there's something that you heard today on the podcast episode and you want to dig deeper into becoming an inventory genius yourself, I want to invite you to head on over to my website, Sierra Stocklin.com, where I have multiple ways that you and I can work together on your inventory. I want to help you with your profit, your cash flow, and your paycheck because at the end of the day, it's all related to your inventory. So head on over to the website and connect with me, I'll work with you soon. See you then.